Endocrine
Perspective
by
GEOFFREY P. REDMOND, M.D.
Past Endocrine Columns
Dear Dr. Redmond:
Sometimes my clients show me their lab results because they find them confusing.
Can you provide some guidelines on the meaning of ‘levels of testosterone’ and
related hormones?
Testosterone
is the sole trigger of hirsutism and acne (and the main cause of alopecia when
it begins before age 40). This potent hormone can be measured in several ways;
unfortunately no single test tells the whole story. Moreover, testosterone
levels are commonly misconstrued, and I never accept a blanket statement that
this test is “normal.”
To understand how
testosterone levels are properly interpreted, you need to know some things about
this hormone that most doctors do not know, though there is nothing truly arcane
about them.
Testosterone is
measured in three different forms. Ninety-eight percent of testosterone in the
blood circulates attached to a protein called SHBG (sex hormone binding
globulin) that also carries estrogen. When hormones are bound to SHBG they are
out of the action, safely trapped in the bloodstream and so unable to escape
into tissues. Only about 2% of testosterone is not attached to SHBG, and is free
to diffuse into tissues, including oil glands and hair follicles: This is
referred to as free testosterone (FT).
Total testosterone
sounds like it would be the most important one, but it is actually FT that
affects a woman’s body. Unfortunately, many of the assays for FT are inaccurate,
so test results give only a general idea of the actual level. SHBG can be
measured, but is less useful.
SHBG is made in the liver and is controlled by the two sex hormones that attach
to it. Estrogen signals the liver to make more SHBG — which results in more
testosterone being bound in the blood. In this way estrogen counters
testosterone, and keeps it in the bloodstream, out of harms way.
Testosterone lowers
SHBG; as levels of this hormone go up, more and more is free to slip out of the
blood into the tis sues — where it wreaks its havoc.
The next problem in
making sense of testosterone levels is that different laboratories give
different normal or ‘reference’ ranges, and we it’s unclear why these vary so
much. The upper normal for total testosterone ranges from 55 to 120 mcg/dL. But
a level of 100 might be considered “a very high level of testosterone” at one
laboratory, and judged to be “normal” at another. My own opinion — based on
seeing thousands of testosterone results in more than 20 years of practice — is
that when the level approaches or exceeds 50, unwanted effects such as acne,
hirsutism and androgenic alopecia are common. The unmeasured variable is, of
course, how each individual reacts to testosterone. The more sensitive a woman’s
oil glands and follicles are to this hormone, the lower the level at which it
will adversely affect her skin and hair.
Like everything else
hormonal, testosterone fluctuates. If blood happens to be drawn during a low
point, the result will be normal for a woman who may have high levels at other
times. Testosterone tends to be highest in the morning, so the best time to have
the test drawn is between 8 a.m. and 10 a.m. Even levels obtained later in the
day can be helpful, however.
So, what’s really
normal? Before accepting a result as normal, we must ask, “normal for what?”
This is a particular point of confusion with respect to hormone tests. A
testosterone level within the normal range means that the ovary and adrenal are
not over-producing this hormone. When the level is significantly elevated it is
essential to find out the source and cause of the over-production. (Possible
causes might include polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), late-onset adrenal
hyperplasia, thecal cell hyperplasia, and tumors (fortunately, extremely rare).
When testosterone is
not elevated it is good news because we are reassured that the function of
ovaries and adrenals is relatively normal, though a normal level does not rule
out mild PCOS. The most important thing to be borne in mind (unfortu nately not
widely known), is that for some women “normal” levels of testosterone can still
cause damage: The test only tells us what the ovaries and adrenals are doing —
it says nothing about how the body responds. For some women even a
borderline-high testosterone level of 50 will not cause noticeable effects. For
others, who have the bad luck to be ultra sensitive to this hormone, even a much
lower level will leave its mark on skin and hair.
Testosterone changes
over time. In women, levels peak in the late teens and early twenties, then
gradually decline. Unfortunately, laboratory reference ranges rarely include a
breakdown by age, which further obscures the meaning of the test because we need
to know what the level means for the patient’s actual age.
The length of exposure
to high levels of testosterone is another critical variable. A total
testosterone level of 50 that lasts for a year is far less damaging than a level
of 45 that persists for a decade. Of course there is no way to measure what past
levels might have been. That is why I emphasize that tests tell part of the
hormonal story, but not all of it.
The most important
thing to be kept in mind is that a “normal” testosterone level does not mean
that this hormone is not the cause of acne, hirsutism or alopecia. Sometimes
women are disappointed when their result is normal, because they think that it
means the cause cannot be found. Actually, testosterone is always the cause of
acne and hirsutism, and often of alopecia. Even when it is normal, treatment to
lower the level or block its effects on skin and hair can be affected.
Past Endocrine Columns